Looking to make a TRULY epic sandwich? Put on a batch of this Olive Salad for Muffalettas! Quick and easy to make, it brings a TON of flavor!
If you’ve ever had a New Orleans Muffaletta, then you’ve had olive salad!
This unique spread is what adds a punch of flavour - and colour - to the famous Louisiana sandwich.
The briny vegetables and flavour-infused olive oil bring some great texture and flavour contrasts to the sandwich, as well. Various degrees of crunch, the salt/vinegar of the brine, and the oil balance out the heft of the meats and cheese in the sandwich.
The oil, specifically, elevates the sandwich.
After sitting on the olive salad mix overnight, the oil picks up a ton of flavour. Drizzle that over your bread as you’re making the sandwich, it soaks in... *chef kiss*.
Anyway, because of that, you’ll want to make this olive salad at least a day before you make your muffalettas.
If you’re an olive person - like us - you may want to double the batch. We do - so keep that in mind when looking at the progress photos!
Muffaletta Olive Spread FAQ
What is muffuletta spread made of?
This can vary from restaurant to restaurant, and person to person. Some use a mix of green and dark olives - kalamata, black, or both. Some use primarily kalamata or black olives.
Some - like me - use Giardiniera, an Italian blend of pickled vegetables, while others may use elements of giardiniera on their own. Carrots, celery, red peppers, cauliflower, etc. Personally, I like the ease of using giardiniera!
From there, it’s the added flavours. Some use capers, most will use pepperoncini, you should definitely use garlic, etc. More on ingredients in a bit, though!
What is in Central Grocery olive salad?
Per the ingredients on their retail jars:
Olives with Pimentos, Oil Blend (Soybean/Extra Virgin Olive Oil), Cauliflower, Carrots, Celery, Kalamata Olives, Red Bell Peppers, Capers, Pepperoncini, Water, Vinegar, Salt, Spices, Garlic and Calcium Chloride, Potassium Sorbate, Lactic Acid, Sodium Bisulfite and Yellow 5 as Preservatives.
How long does Muffaletta salad last in the fridge?
Because everything is brined already, then topped with olive oil, this spread will stay good for a LONG time in the fridge.
How long it lasts depends on two things: The expiry dates on the canned/jarred foods that you use, and how you take care of it.
For the longest use, use clean - or even sterilized - jars when packing it. When dishing it out, use a clean fork to scoop it out, leaving a fair amount of olive oil behind. If you notice the olive oil getting low, top it up a bit.
When taken care of, this spread will last for several months or more, no problem.
How do you make Muffuletta Sandwiches?
Glad you asked! You’ll want to go check out my Muffaletta Sandwich Recipe post for all of the details. 🙂
Muffaletta Olive Salad Ingredients
Olives
Pretty straightforward. I like to go with a 1:1 olive mix, using both green olives with pimento, and black olives.
Feel free to use kalamata olives if you prefer - I do, sometimes!
Also, feel free to use a different proportion of olives, if you like - just try to keep it to the same overall volume of olives.
Giardiniera
This is a type of Italian mixed vegetable pickle, which you can usually find in the pickles section at a grocery store. Generally, you’ll see cauliflower, carrot, onions, celery, and strips of red pepper in any jar of giardiniera.
Also, sometimes you’ll have a choice of regular, or hot. Use whichever you prefer!
Pepperoncini
These are a relatively mild kind of pickled Italian chili pepper, which you’ll also find in the pickles section of a grocery store.
They add a bit of a pepper kick to the olive tapenade, and you can use as many or as few as you’d like. I used to go by “Half a small jar worth”, but now it’s really just whatever I’m in the mood for.
Just be sure to drain them again after you cut them open - they tend to hold a lot of the pickling brine!
Herbs
Pretty basic - parsley (I use Italian / flat leaf, but you can use curly if that’s more convenient!), dried oregano, garlic, and ground pepper.
Olive Oil
The final ingredient is an important one, as it ties it all together.
You don’t have to use super premium oil, but be sure to use one that you like the taste of!
The main ingredients for making Muffaletta Olive Tapenade.
How to Make Muffuletta Olive Salad
Full recipe follows (end of the post), but here’s a pictorial overview:
Chop olives and giardiniera, place in a large bowl.
Trim the stem ends off the pepperoncini, allow any trapped brine to drain. Chop, add to the large bowl.
Measure parsley, oregano, and garlic into the bowl, stir well to combine.
Season with ground pepper, to taste, before stirring in the olive oil.
Pack mixture into clean glass jars, making sure to top each jar with olive oil from the bowl.
Transfer to fridge. Ideally, allow it to chill for at least 24 hours before using.
More Seasoning & Condiment Recipes
Looking for some healthy recipes for tasty ways to add a little something extra to your dish? Here are a few ideas:
Basil Pesto
Berbere Seasoning
Canadian Popcorn Seasonings
Chow Chow Relish
Cilantro-Mint Chutney
Diana Sauces (Replica Recipes)
Hop Extracts
Seasoned Salt
Roasted Garlic
Vanilla Extract
Homemade Mayonnaise
Furikake Seasoning
Honey Dill Dipping Sauce
Honey Garlic Cooking Sauce
Hoppy Dill Pickle Relish
How to Make Compound Butters
Montreal Steak Spice & Marinade
Porter's Yogurt & Ice Cream Topping
Roasted Beet Ketchup
Smoky Dry Rub for Wings
Sushi Sauce Recipes
Tangerine Thyme Dry Rub
Thai Cilantro Pesto
Share the Love!
Before you chow down, be sure to take some pics of your handiwork! If you post it to Bluesky, be sure to tag us - @CelebrationGen. We're also on Pinterest, so you can save all your favourite recipes to a board!
Also, be sure to subscribe to my free monthly email newsletter, so you never miss out on any of my nonsense.
Well, the published nonsense, anyway!
Olive Salad for Muffalettas
Equipment
- Food processor Optional, but nice to have!
Ingredients
- 1 ½ cups Green Olives with Pimento Drained
- 1 ½ cups Pitted black olives drained
- ¾ Cup Giardiniera drained
- 5-10 Pepperoncini Drained
- 1 tablespoon Fresh Italian Parsley Finely chopped
- 1 tablespoon Dried Oregano
- 1 tablespoon Finely Minced Garlic
- Ground Pepper
- ¾ Cups Olive Oil
Instructions
- Chop olives and giardiniera, place in a large bowl.
- Trim the stem ends off the pepperoncini, allow any trapped brine to drain. Chop, add to the large bowl.
- Measure parsley, oregano, and garlic into the bowl, stir well to combine.
- Season with ground pepper, to taste, before stirring in the olive oil.
- Pack mixture into clean glass jars, making sure to top each jar with olive oil from the bowl.
- Transfer to fridge. Ideally, allow it to chill for at least 24 hours before using.
Notes
Nutrition
Helen A Bouchard
This is absolutely delicious! We use it daily on sandwiches. I'm about to make my second batch.
Susan Kruse
So much better to make yourself as the store jars have soybean oil and don’t taste as amazing!
Aimee
Does it matter the size of the green olives? Thx
Marie Porter
Not really.
Deanna
This is absolutely amazing! Assuming we don’t immediately plow through the entire jar, how long will it keep in the refrigerator?
Marie Porter
I tend to go by whatever the soonest expiry date is on the ingredients, for something like this.