Easter No Bake Chocolate Pie

Pie season may have ended a few months ago, but I like to think of no bake chocolate pie as a great option for satisfying your chocolate cravings, year round.

Unlike French silk pie - which involves raw eggs and more steps - this is an easy chocolate pie to make.

The homemade crust whips up in just minutes - and making your own crust tastes SO much better than off-the-shelf crusts.

This chocolate cream pie recipe is adapted from one of my pudding recipes - the addition of eggs is all it took to convert it to the perfect chocolate pie filling.

While my homemade chocolate pie is great any time of the year - and no bake desserts are particularly nice in summer - I actually developed this no bake chocolate pie recipe specifically for Easter!

I love, love, LOVE Cadbury Mini Eggs, and always love an excuse to have them on hand 🙂 Not only are they tasty, they look super cute when piled up on this chocolate lover’s dream of a pie!

Anyway, let’s get to it...

Chocolate Pie Recipe Ingredients

This creamy chocolate pie is made up of simple ingredients, but there’s a handful of them. I have a few notes on some of the ingredients themselves, the full list of ingredients with measurements is included in the recipe card at the end of this post.

Chocolate Cookie Crust

The Oreo cookie crust is super simple to make, and only involves 2 ingredients: oreo cookies and butter.

I used an entire small package of Oreo cookies for this Oreo crust - 24 cookies.

I break them up before running them through the food processor, filling and all. I find that the filling helps stick the crust together.

While this is a no bake pie recipe, you CAN bake the crust if you want - I have directions for that option further down in the “variations” section.

Chocolate Cream Filling

While some chocolate pie fillings involve instant chocolate pudding mix, I like to make mine from scratch. I just find it tastes better and cuts cleaner.

This chocolate pudding filling started out as my chocolate pudding recipe, but with the addition of egg yolks - this is what helps it set up firmer, to slice nicely.

Chocolate Chips

I call for milk chocolate chips in this recipe, to go along with the Cadbury Mini Eggs. I just find milk chocolate to feel more “Easter” to me, than any other type.

The quality of chocolate will affect the flavour and texture of your finished chocolate pie filling, so I recommend using high quality chocolate chips.

Guittard Milk Chocolate Chips, Ghirardelli Milk Chocolate Chips, and Callebaut Milk Chocolate Callets are all great options.

The Other Pie Filling Ingredients

Aside from the chocolate, you will need:

Whole milk
Granulated Sugar
Large egg yolks
Cornstarch
Unsalted butter
Vanilla extract
Salt

Stabilized Whipped Cream & Topping

Stabilized whipped cream is slightly more effort than basic homemade whipped cream - or using something like Cool Whip - but it’s worth it.

The addition of gelatin helps the whipped cream maintain its shape, and prevents it from breaking down / “weeping” as it sits.

This makes it ideal for a dessert that you would serve at an Easter gathering - you can make it ahead of time, and even travel with it!

Just note: you’ll want to spread and pipe it soon after making it, though - before the gelatin sets!

Anyway, to make this whipped topping, you will need:

Heavy whipping cream
Icing sugar / powdered sugar / confectioners’ sugar
Unflavored gelatin powder
Vanilla extract

In addition to the whipped cream, there’s the garnish : Chocolate sauce (optional), and Cadbury Mini Eggs!

Personally, I think Mini Eggs are the best thing about this season... well, after Paska Easter Bread, anyway!

I used 4 tiny packets, I think they were 33g each. A couple 100 gram packets or a 200 gram packet would also work.

How to Make No Bake Chocolate Cream Pie

This recipe comes together in a few parts - the crust, the filling, the topping, and the decoration. It’s a lot of info, but it really does come together quickly!

The full recipe is in the recipe card at the end of the post, this is a pictorial overview, with more information included.

Chocolate Cookie Crust:

Grease a 9 inch pie pan with butter or shortening, set aside.

Crumble the Oreos a bit, then blitz in your food processor - filling and all - until finely ground.

Pour crumbs into a medium bowl. Add melted butter to the mixing bowl, stir well to combine.

Dump the mixture into your pie plate. Distribute crust mixture evenly over the pan, press firmly to form a pie shell with even thickness throughout.

I'll usually use a small glass to press it all firmly into place.

Chocolate Cream Filling:

In a medium saucepan, whisk together the sugar, cornstarch, and salt.

In a separate bowl, beat the egg yolks. Add milk - a bit at a time - whisking until well combined. Add this mixture to the pot, whisking to fully combine.

Once everything is fully combined - and being careful to scrape the bottom of the pan - bring to a just to a boil over medium-high heat, whisking constantly.

As the mixture starts to boil, turn heat down to low and continue to simmer until quite thick. Remove from heat.

Immediately add the chocolate, butter, and vanilla. Whisk constantly until the chocolate and butter are completely melted and everything is well incorporated into the chocolate mixture. Melted chocolate should be completely distributed throughout.

Pour chocolate filling into the cooled pie crust, using an offset or rubber spatula or the back of a spoon to smooth and flatten the top of the filling.

Note: You may find yourself with air bubbles on the surface of your pie. You can pop them with a toothpick - do this as soon as possible, before the pie sets up!

Cover with plastic wrap - right against the surface of the filling - and chill for 8 hours. For best results, I like to chill it overnight.

Stabilized Whipped Cream:

Sprinkle gelatin over the cold water in a small bowl and let it absorb for five minutes.

Combine heavy whipping cream, powdered sugar, and flavor extract in a mixing bowl - if using a hand mixer - or in the bowl of a stand mixer set up with a whisk attachment. Whip until soft peaks start to form.

Transfer gelatin mixture to the microwave. Heat in 10 second increments until the gelatin dissolves into the water.

Fold gelatin mixture to cream mixture, then whip until stiff peaks form.

To Assemble:

Crush some of the mini eggs - I put them in a plastic baggie and roll over it with a rolling pin - sprinkle over the rosettes.

Spread ½ of the whipped cream evenly over the chocolate pie filling, smoothing the top of the pie with a hot offset spatula if desired.

Pipe a lattice of chocolate sauce over the top of the whipped cream, if you’d like.

Spoon remaining whipped cream into a pastry bag set with a large star tip.

Pipe rosettes of whipped cream around the edge of the pie, as shown.

Finish off with whole mini eggs, chill until serving.

Variations

While this pie is fantastic as-is, there’s definitely room to customize it to your preferences. Here are some ideas:

Baked Oreo Cookie Crust

This crust works as both an unbaked cookie crust, or a baked one. IMHO baking it makes it a bit more solid, but it’s not necessary.

If you want to bake the pie crust, bake it for 9 minutes at 350 F.

While it’s still hot, re-press it into shape and allow it to fully cool to room temperature before filling.

Richer filling

Feel free to swap out the granulated sugar for some packed brown sugar, to give an even richer chocolate flavor.

Dark Chocolate Filling

You can swap out the milk chocolate chips for dark chocolate, for a less over-the-top sweet pie.

Add to the Garnish

Want even more chocolate?

Add some chocolate sprinkles in with the crushed Cadbury Mini Eggs, or use a vegetable peeler to make some chocolate shavings to add with the whole mini eggs.

Make a Quick Chocolate Ganache

No chocolate sauce? I tend to whip up a quick chocolate ganache to pipe on.

I’ll just measure ¼ cup chocolate and about 1 teaspoon of butter and 2 teaspoon Heavy whipping cream into a microwave safe bowl or measuring cup. Heat it for 30 seconds at a time until melted, then thin out with a little bit of heavy cream if necessary. Pipe it while it’s hot, and it will set up as it cools.

I’ll set up a small cup with the pastry bag - holding it in place while I fill it, to make that whole thing quicker, easier, and cleaner.

Year Round No Bake Chocolate Pie

While I would personally eat Mini Eggs all year round if available, I can understand not wanting to serve an aggressively Easter themed dessert in October!

Swap out the mini eggs for chopped mini peanut butter cups, M & Ms, chopped peppermint patties, or whatever other chocolate candy makes sense at the time!

More Easter Content!

Looking for more fun / tasty ways to observe Easter? Here are a few suggestions:

Chocolate Zombie Easter Bunnies
Easter Creme Egg Brownies
Easter Pavlova
Easy Pysanky [Epic Easter Eggs]
Gluten-Free Paska [Easter Bread]
Keto Paska
Paska - Ukrainian Easter Bread
Southern Comfort Glazed Ham

Share the Love!

Before you chow down, be sure to take some pics of your handiwork! If you Instagram it, be sure to tag me - @CelebrationGenerationCA - or post it to My Facebook Page - so I can cheer you on!

Also, be sure to subscribe to my free monthly email newsletter, so you never miss out on any of my nonsense. Well, the published nonsense, anyway!

Finally, if you love this recipe, please consider leaving a star review and/or a comment below!