Pumpernickel Everything Bagels

These deep, dark pumpernickel bagels are loaded with flavour, featuring caraway seeds both inside and out. Easier to make than you may think!

Originally posted March 26, 2020. Updated 6/6/2021

They say that "Necessity is the Mother of Invention", and I've always found that to be true.

Lately, the whole ... 2020 situation ... has been bringing that whole theory to reality for a lot of people - including for me and my husband.

For his part, my husband has been building. I now have a custom set of planters, designed specifically to be attached to the top railings of our back mini-deck, for easy access from the kitchen.

When I injured my foot badly enough to not be able to put ANY weight on it this past weekend, he went out to the garage and came back less than 2 hours later with a homemade knee scooter, from whatever he had on hand.

I'd bastardize a quote from Red Green and say "If you can't marry handsome, you should marry handy", but I lucked out and got both 🙂 Anyway!

Pumpernickel Bagels

About a month ago, I kind of put my foot down on certain aspects of grocery shopping.

I know I probably seemed a little paranoid at the time, but I saw what was coming - so no more buying easily-bruised (and therefore hard to REALLY wash) fruits out of bins... and no more buying fresh bakery goods displayed out in the open.

Sensible, IMHO... but it meant no more of my husband's favourite bagels for the foreseeable future. (When things go back to normal: Starsky's in Hamilton. Amazing bagels!)

SO, this morning I finally got around to doing something I've had in the back of my head for a while : retooling my basic bagel recipe *completely*, to create a proper pumpernickel recipe for him.

Pumpernickel Everything Bagels

I ended up going a little wild with it, and just completely tricking it out to his taste (and, to a lesser degree... what we have on hand. No whole wheat flour, as a result!).

I combined his two favourite bagel types - Pumpernickel, and "Everything", tweaking the "Everything" topping to better work with Pumpernickel (No poppyseeds, but adding caraway seeds)...

... having caraway seeds in the bagel, adding a little honey in the boil to get a bit of sweet faux-caramelization on the crust during the bake, AND having cornmeal on the bottom (Totally optional, btw).

He took one bite, said "I love you MORE!", and declared them to be even better than Starskys. WOW. I was hoping for "Good enough for a quarantine substitute, for now".

Luckily, these are easy enough to make, that anyone can do it. It doesn't take any special skills or equipment, just a little bit of patience as the dough rises.

I hope you enjoy these as much as he does!

Looking for a more basic rye bagel? Try my Rye Bagels with Caraway Seeds!

How to Make Pumpernickel Everything Bagels

Make The Dough

Pour water and coffee into a microwave-safe bowl. Stir in molasses and yeast, allow to stand for 10 minutes – it should get very bubbly.

In a large mixing bowl, combine flours, cocoa powder, caraway seeds and salt.

Pour in yeast mixture and oil, stir well to combine.

Dump the dough out onto a floured surface, knead until soft and elastic, 5-10 minutes. Alternately, use a stand mixer with a dough hook to "knead" it until smooth and elastic.

Place dough in a greased bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and allow to rise for one hour, or until doubled in size.

Form the Bagel Dough

Once dough has doubled, punch it down, and divide it out. We divided the mixture into 6 equally sized balls, for large bagels.

You can divide into 8 for medium-large bagels, or 10- 12 for smaller bagels.

Preheat oven to 350 F. Line 1-2 baking sheets with parchment paper, scatter cornmeal across if desired. (Optional!)

There are two main ways of forming bagels

1 - With roll each lump of dough into a thick “snake” and secure the ends together, or

2 - Roll each lump into a smooth ball before poking a finger though. Once you have a hole made, stretch the ring of dough out a bit to enlarge the hole.

Personally, I prefer the latter, pictured.

Once you have all of your bagels formed, set them on a baking sheet to rise for another 10 minutes.

Cook the Bagels

In a large pot, combine water and honey, bring to a boil. I like to lay a sheet of parchment paper out across the other half of the stove, as my work surface.

Turn heat down a little, allowing water to simmer rather than continue to boil.

2 or 3 at a time, drop your bagels into the simmering water, allow to cook for 1 minute, then flip each and allow to cook for another minute.

Drain well, place on the parchment-lined work surface, allow to cool slightly.

Whisk egg together with 1 tablespoon of water, brush over the tops and sides of each bagel.

Combine the remaining ingredients in a wide, shallow bowl.

One at a time, pick up each bagel, gently invert into the bowl, and swirl around to coat the tops and sides.

Place topping side up on baking sheets, as you finish each.

Bake for about 35 minutes (if you’re making 10-12), 37 minutes (for 8), or 40-45 mins (If you’re doing 6 large ones), until golden brown.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe Save Recipe Saved!

4.87 from 15 votes

Pumpernickel Everything Bagels

These deep, dark pumpernickel bagels are loaded with flavour, and feature caraway seeds both inside and out. Don’t be intimidated by the idea of making bagels, it’s easier than you might think!

Prep Time30 minutes mins

Cook Time37 minutes mins

Rising Time1 hour hr 10 minutes mins

Total Time2 hours hrs 17 minutes mins

Course: Bread, Breakfast

Cuisine: German

Servings: 8 Bagels

Calories: 317kcal

Author: Marie Porter

Equipment

2 Baking Sheets

Parchment Paper

Ingredients

Dough

• ¾ cup Warm Water
• ½ cup Brewed Coffee
• ⅓ cup Molasses
• 4 teaspoon Active Dry Yeast
• 2 cups All Purpose flour
• 1 ¼ cup Rye Flour
• ⅓ cup Cocoa Powder
• 1 tablespoon Caraway Seeds
• 2 teaspoon Salt
• 2 tablespoon Vegetable Oil

Assembly

• Cornmeal Optional
• 3 L Hot Water
• ¼ cup Honey
• 1 Large Egg
• 1 tablespoon Water
• 2 tablespoon Sesame Seeds
• 1 ½ tablespoon Caraway Seeds
• 1 ½ tablespoon Dried Minced Onion
• 1 tablespoon Garlic Flakes
• 1 tablespoon Coarse Salt

Instructions

• Pour water and coffee into a microwave safe bowl. Stir in molasses and yeast, allow to stand for 10 minutes – it should get very bubbly.
• In a large mixing bowl, combine flours, cocoa powder, caraway seeds and salt. Pour in yeast mixture and oil, stir well to combine.
• Dump dough out onto a floured surface, knead until soft and elastic, 5-10 minutes. Place dough in a greased bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and allow to rise for one hour, or until doubled in size.
• Once dough has doubled, punch it down, and divide it out. We divided the mixture into 8 equally sized balls, a medium-large bagel. You can divide into 6 for LARGE bagels, or 10- 12 for smaller bagels.
• Preheat oven to 350 F. Line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper, scatter cornmeal across if desired. (Optional!)
• There are two main ways of forming bagels – with roll each lump of dough into a thick “snake” and secure the ends together, or roll each lump into a smooth ball before poking a finger though. Once you have a hole made, stretch the ring of dough out a bit to enlarge the hole. Personally, I prefer the latter.
• Once you have all of your bagels formed, set them on a baking sheet to rise for another 10 minutes.
• In a large pot, combine water and honey, bring to a boil. I like to lay a sheet of parchment paper out across the other half of the stove, as my work surface.
• Turn heat down a little, allowing water to simmer rather than continue to boil. 2 or 3 at a time, drop your bagels into the simmering water, allow to cook for 1 minute, then flip each and allow to cook for another minute. Drain well, place on the parchment lined work surface, allow to cool slightly.
• Whisk egg together with 1 tablespoon of water, brush over the tops and sides of each bagel.
• Combine remaining ingredients in a wide, shallow bowl. One at a time, pick up each bagel, gently invert into the bowl, and swirl around to coat the tops and sides. Place topping side up on baking sheets, as you finish each.
• Bake for about 37 minutes (for 8), 35 minutes (if you’re making 10-12), or 40-45 mins (If you’re doing 6 large ones), until golden brown.

Nutrition

Calories: 317kcal | Carbohydrates: 60g | Protein: 8g | Fat: 7g | Saturated Fat: 3g | Cholesterol: 20mg | Sodium: 1472mg | Potassium: 443mg | Fiber: 6g | Sugar: 20g | Vitamin A: 30IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 81mg | Iron: 4mg

Related posts:

Jalapeno Cheddar Beer Bagels Buffalo Chicken Buns Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls How to Make Bagels