Revisiting an iconic childhood poem, I learned that “Alligator Pie” - isn’t actually a thing. This Alligator Pie Recipe rights that wrong!
Originally Posted October 1, 2014. Updated 2/11/2023
A few weeks ago, my friend Charlotte posted something to the effect of "When I say 'Alligator Pie', you say what?" as a Facebook status. To me, the answer was obvious - "If I don't get some, I think I'm going to die!".
She ended up getting some weird responses, none seeming to know what she was talking about.
I had assumed the book to be British, on account of the style of artwork I remembered from it ... and if it had been crazy popular back home, surely her American friends had heard of it, right?
Well, I guess I should have realized it from the hockey references... but as it turns out, the book is Canadian. I guess that explains the confusion!
This time of year, I end up obsessed with Alligator meat.
It finally cooled down enough for me to attend the Minnesota Renaissance Festival a couple weeks ago, and - in my mind - the alligator sausage there is the absolute best part of fest. (Aside from all my friends that work there, I mean!).
Shortly after our day at fest, I happened across some frozen alligator meat in the grocery store, so I picked it up... thinking I'd make some sausage at home.
Well, having "Alligator Pie" stuck in my head, I ended up deciding that I should make some.
I knew "Alligator Pie" existed in a few different incarnations as a dessert... some as a green coloured cream pie, others more like a pecan pie, with the nutty surface being representative of alligator skin.
However, I had never heard of an ACTUAL alligator pie. As one of the most literal people ever (Seriously, Drax is my patronus)... it had to happen.
Because there wasn't really something pre-existing, I could pretty much do whatever I want!
I decided to start with a proper cajun trinity - onion, celery, and green peppers - as a nod to gator meat as a very southern thing.
... Says the Canadian, making a pie about a beloeved Canadian poem!
The recipe would be flavoured with some of the same seasonings I could taste in the alligator sausage that I loved so much... but only as an accent.
I didn't want it to be a sausage pie, after all. I wanted it to be like the savoury pies I'd grown up with - some meat, some vegetables, a little gravy, and a ton of flavour.
This ended up a huge hit with both my husband and a couple other friends that happened to pop by the night I made it... including The Pink Dalek, who almost didn't share with her mom!
The meat was tender and juicy, and the flavours all worked very well together.
This recipe will work well with your favourite pie crust recipe, or even with store bought crust.
Gluten-Free Alligator Pie
Looking for a tasty gluten-free pie crust (the filling is inherently gf!)?
You should buy a copy of my book, Beyond Flour - pie crust is only one of the many "as good or better than the gluteny original!" recipes in there.
This recipe is one of many fantastic Canadian recipes in my cookbook, "More Than Poutine: Favourite Foods from my Home and Native Land”. "More than Poutine" is a Canadian cookbook like no other - written by a Canadian living away, it includes both traditional home cooking recipes, as well as accurate homemade versions of many of the snacks, sauces, convenience foods, and other food items that are hard to come by outside of Canada! Order your copy here on this site, through Amazon, or through any major bookseller!
More “Sounds Weird, but it WORKS!” Recipes
Got a bit of a sense of adventure in the kitchen? Here are some more recipes that sound weird, but actually work!
Canadian Candy Bar Salad
Cardamom Fig Pavlova
Crab Rangoon Pizza
Dill Pickle Gummy Worms
Hopped Cheesecake with Citrus Glaze
How to Make Haggis
Moon Mist Ice Cream
Moroccan Twist Salted Caramel Popcorn
Pumpkin Spice Nanaimo Bars
Spicy Southern Comfort Glazed Chicken
Sweet Corn Ice Cream
Share the Love!
Well, the published nonsense, anyway!
Savoury Alligator Pie
- 2 tablespoon butter
- 1 large onion chopped
- 1 green pepper chopped
- 3 stalks celery chopped
- 4 cloves garlic pressed or finely minced
- 1 lb alligator meat cut into small pieces
- 1 lb pork loin cut into small pieces
- 1 teaspoon dried sage
- ¼ dried oregano
- Pinch dried thyme
- pinch cayenne powder
- ½ cup chicken broth or dry white wine
- 2 teaspoon corn starch
- Salt and pepper
- 1 double crust recipe of pie dough prepared (or store bought)
- 1 egg beaten
- 1 tablespoon water
- Preheat oven to 425 F
- In a large pan, melt butter. Add onion, peppers, and celery, cook until veggies start to soften. Add garlic, meats, and seasonings, continue cooking until meat is browned. For a finer texture filling (as pictured), I transferred the mixture to my food processor and blitzed it a few times, but this is optional.
- Whisk together broth and corn starch until smooth. Add to pan, bring to a boil. Allow to cook until liquid becomes quite thick. Remove from heat, season with salt and pepper to taste.
- Divide dough into 2 parts – one slightly bigger than the other. Roll the bigger section out , use it to line a deep-dish pie pan* – carefully working it into the corners. Fill pie pan with alligator filling, spreading it into the bottom edge and mounding it in the center.
- Roll out the second part of dough, cover the pie filling. Crimp the edges as desired, poke a couple of slits in the top. If desired, roll any extra dough very thin, cut into shapes, and apply to the crust for decoration. Whisk together egg and water, brush over the entire top of pie.
- Whisk the egg together with water, use a pastry brush to coat the entire crust with a thin wash of this glaze. Cut thin strips of aluminum foil, gently wrap over the outside edge of the crust to protect it from burning.
- Bake for 30 minutes, remove foil, and continue baking for another 10 minutes, or until crust is golden brown. Serve hot!
Looking for More Pie Recipes?
Pies, tarts... good stuff put into a flaky crust. I've got you!
Note: All recipes designated as gluten-free can alternately be made "regular" - just swap in your favourite pie crust recipe or store bought crust!
Caramel Apple Pie
Creamy Blueberry Amaretto Pie
Earl Grey Pie
Easter No-Bake Chocolate Pie
Gluten Free Apple Pie
Gluten-Free Maple Pumpkin Pie
Gluten Free Pie Crust
Maple Butter Tarts
Perfect Pie Crust Recipe
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
Southern Comfort Peach Pie
Southern Comfort Pecan Pie
Strawberry Grand Marnier Chiffon Pie