Pecan Pie Cookies
Originally published September 22, 2011, Updated on 10/10/20
These unique cookies are full of great pecan flavour, have a great texture, and are so pretty to look at. What more could you want in a cookie?
I’ve been a bit conflicted over posting this Pecan Pie Cookies recipe.
Generally speaking, every recipe I post is something that I’ve either developed completely from scratch, or a family recipe that I’ve tweaked over the years.
Sometimes, it’ll be a “Frankenstein” recipe, utilizing bits and pieces of ingredients and techniques of several of my recipes - like my Jamaican Beef Patties recipe.
This pecan pie cookies recipe? I’ve had it for years, but I now have NO idea where it originally came from.
I’m pretty sure it came from one of the posters on a cake forum I used to frequent, but who specifically, or where SHE got it from? No idea. It looks like it’s since become a popular recipe out there on the interwebs, though!
Anyway - way back when - I asked for permission to use this recipe as a holiday offering through Celebration Generation... and the cookies always got rave reviews. (I know this much, at least, because I asked permission for any not-my-own recipes, when starting out!)
I can’t count how many times I’ve been asked for the recipe! What with the weather cooling down, I figure it’s cookie making season, and time to share it!
I don’t think I have contributed any major changes to the recipe (It’s been too long to remember!), but I like to add a couple pinches of spice to the filling, as noted.
Hope I’m not losing any baker’s cred by posting this, but I know it’ll make a bunch of people happy. Plus, I think the photos are just too pretty to NOT share.
(A note on the updated photos: I redeveloped this recipe for inclusion in Beyond Flour, as a gluten-free Pecan Pie Cookie... and those are the photos now shown here.
They look exactly the same, I’m just too lazy to make and shoot a batch of full-gluten cookies for the photos!)
More Holiday Treats
Looking for more inspiration for your holiday goodies tray? Whether Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, or any of the other holidays, here are a few ideas for you!
Blood Orange Cranberry Toffee
Boozy Chocolate Haystack Cookies
Candied Orange Slices
Creme de Menthe Nanaimo Bars
Festive Easy Fudge
Fruitcake Cookies
Gluten-Free Fruitcake
Gluten-Free Fruitcake Cookies
Noelles
Pecan Pie Cookies
Peppermint Patties
Sweet Ecstasy Cookies
Share the Love!
Before you chow down, be sure to take some pics of your handiwork! If you Instagram it, be sure to tag me - @OverlordMarie - or post it to My Facebook Page - so I can cheer you on!
Also, be sure to subscribe to my free monthly email newsletter, so you never miss out on any of my nonsense.
Well, the published nonsense, anyway!
Oh. My. Gawd!! These look so darn yummy I can't stand it! I'll have to make them for the next business pot luck just so I can have some. Thanks for posting.
I was so excited to see this recipe on Pinterest. My husband loves pecan pie. I attempted to make the cookies but found the dough just ran when baking. I thought it looked too wet (like it needed more flour) after mixing it, but since it was my first time making it, decided to follow the recipe. Any suggestions?
Hi Deborrah.
Hrm.. no idea what to suggest, I've never had that happen before, or heard from anyone who has. After the flour is mixed in, it should definitely be dry enough to roll balls from - if it happens again, I'd add more flour.
Make sure the butter for the dough is room temperature, and NOT melted. I made this mistake years ago, when making chocolate chip cookes, and they turned out like pancakes, not cookies! lol
I made these today! I had some problems with rolling the dough into balls (it was too sticky), so I tried two methods to combat the problem:
1. Half of the dough I used two spoons to scoop the ball into ball shapes, then refrigerated the dough so it would tighten up a bit. Then I used the back of the teaspoon, dipped in flour to make the dent in the middle. They turned out well!
2. To the half of the dough I had left I added 1/3 cup of flour, which made the dough more manageable. I still couldn't roll the dough, so I used the spoons again. This did make the cookies a little drier.
In the end, they were yummy! Taste like a homemade pecan sandy mixed with pecan pie!
Possibly Cut the butter down from 3/4 cup to 3/4 stick. To much butter thins the dough as it cooks.
I think your issue is definitely the flour. Measuring flour by volume (ie cups) isn't ideal because it all depends how much you pack it into the cups. However since most recipes don't give you the weight you need to feel it out on your own. My suggestion would be to make the dough, then add flour until it is ok to work with (personally I like my cookies very flour-y). I do this with chocolate chip cookies too. Here is a link that helped me a lot with my cookies http://theperfectchocolatechipcookie.com/instruct.php about half way down the page is says "problems" and shows cookies that are messed up and their solutions. Hope that helps!
I made these cookies a couple of weeks ago for the first time -- my husband informed me I never needed to make pecan pie again. 😉 I am now on my third round of making these cookies, this time for a bake sale benefiting a local family whose home burned down. What a DELICIOUS recipe. Thanks for sharing!
I saw these on Pinterest and just made these today, and I must say that they are fabulous! The only change I made was to add 1/2 tsp. salt to the dough. I was a little skeptical and didn't think they would taste like pecan pie, but holy smokes they do! Thanks for the recipe!
I had the same problem as Deborrah 🙁 Followed the recipe exactly as well, no problem rolling the dough into balls.
Can these be made a few days ahead?
Definitely, but they may not last 🙂
OMG ... Just pulled these out of the oven! Heavenly and you need a tall glass of milk with just one cookie. But of course, I did not stop with one!!!!!
After reading the posts and before I make this recipe I would like to know the egg size used.
Perhaps that made a softer dough.
Large
These sound so good, I am going to double the recipe when I make them. 20 cookies does not seem like enough. 🙂 Thank you so much for the recipe!
The first time I made these following the recipe minus the spices, the cookies spread quite a bit but were super yummy. I made them again today, and chilled the dough for about 10 minutes and they came out like the picture. The only problem was that the cookies were a little more like a shortbread and a little bit dry. Conclusion, loose dough makes loose cookies that are crispy, cold dough makes firm cookies that a a little dry
Would like to try these.
These turned out perfect and delicious! I did chill the dough a little but found then they cracked more when I made the thumbprint. Excellent recipe!
Are you suppose to add cream to the dough too? That's the very first thing it says to add (cream butter and sugar for the dough) ... Maybe that's why others cookies are runny?
no Sara by creaming butter they mean to mix it well do not add cream to dough just filling
made these today soooo good going to serve them to family later today if I can keep my hand out of cookie jar doubled the recipe worked perfect was thinking they would also be yummy with dab of pumpkin pie filling and cream cheese icing
I think the problem with spreading is the baking powder. It produces a much softer cookie than baking soda.
I made these today and they just taste like sugar cookies with plain pecans on top. I assume they are supposed to taste like more than that? Not trying to be rude, I just want to figure out what went wrong. I followed the recipe exactly, and the filling had flavor before it was baked.
if short on time could a premade sugar cookie or snickerdoodle cookie dough be used instead?
Made these for the first time today thinking I would take a batch to my son's class at school for their Thanksgiving feast. (Easier and less messy than pecan pie!) They are delicious! Fairly easy to make, and I had all the ingredients on hand. I too had the problem with the dough being super sticky, which made the cookies spread a LOT in the oven. I did not melt the butter. Just left it out on the counter for an hour or so this morning. Followed the directions to a T as well. Next time, I will omit the baking powder and add more flour until the dough seems firmer. I will definitely make them again because they are really yummy!
I really want to make these, they look delicious. One question though, all purpose flour or self-rising flour??
All purpose!
In the listing of ingredients, I presume the first listing is the cookie part and the second half the topping...is there really a cup of brown sugar in the dough? Only wondering because it doesn't mention mixing it in, in the directions section, except for the topping with the pecans....
Never mind, I must be tired, lol.
These cookies are a HUGE hit among my friends/family. No problems whatsoever!
My first batch is out of the oven and they look and smell amazing. Recipe was for 20 cookies, but I got 42 good sized cookies from this recipe. If you substitute dark brown sugar in the dough as I did, you will have a darker cookie than the photo. But, oh yum!
I am very disappointed in these cookies. While the flavor is nice, the dough simply does not hold up - as many other bakers experienced.
Even after thoroughly chilling the dough, it runs and becomes very thin while baking. The topping is quite heavy, so it settles through the runny dough and sticks to the cookie sheet. Utter disaster!
Not sure what to say. I've made this recipe many, many times, and have never once had the dough turn out "runny".
Found from pinterest! These turned out great for me! Taking them to a work Christmas party tomorrow! They are really good should be a crowd pleaser!!
I got quite a few more than 20 out of my batch. More than than double that and I stuck right to the recipe.. I found this incredibly easy. 5 *****!!
Just a thought for those that are having trouble with a 'runny' dough, sometimes it can make a huge difference where abouts in the oven you place the baking tray. I always cook one tray at a time in the middle of the oven, allowing the air to circulate the tray on both sides.
Made them, no problems, turned out great. Everyone raved !
Made these this evening and got 26 mid-sized cookies. Did not have any problems with the dough. I made sure when creaming the butter and sugar, that it was fluffy, and then used my hand mixer again to combine the final ingredients until light and fluffy. The egg acts as a binding agent (I think) so it really needs to be beaten in good! Good flavor, though I wish the filling was a bit richer. Will play around with this recipe!
I bake all the time but my cookies did not come out like the picture....I will try to refrigerate the dough if I try them again.
Recipe needs salt. Also, they spread less if chilled after forming the little cups. Other than that, these are great. Thanks for sharing.
I have to show thanks to the writer just for rescuing me from this instance. After checking through the the web and getting basics which are not pleasant, I assumed my life was over. Existing devoid of the solutions to the problems you've sorted out all through your main article content is a critical case, and those that could have in a wrong way damaged my entire career if I had not come across your site. The skills and kindness in touching everything was crucial. I'm not sure what I would've done if I had not discovered such a subject like this. I can also at this time look ahead to my future. Thanks for your time so much for your expert and result oriented help. I won't hesitate to endorse your web sites to anybody who ought to have guidelines about this subject.
I just made these and they were amazing!!!!! I didnt have any problems with my dough and they formed perfectly! Loved them!
Thank you so much for this recipe, will add this to my Christmas cookies.
I placed a whole pecan on top of the cookies after I added the chopped pecan/spice mix (my family LOVES pecans). It made for a beautiful presentation!
I just made these today and....OMG! They are wonderful!!!!! Thank you!
How long will these cookies last for? Since there's cream in the filling do they need to be refrigerated?
They don't last long, but it's not because of the cream! (No need to refrigerate).
Honestly, I'm not sure, We've never had a batch hang around for more than a couple of days, so it's been hard to test that.
Made these for thanksgiving instead of my usual pecan pie and they are amazing. Only thing
I did differently was mix about 1/4 cup chopped pecans into the dough (saw this in another recipe) and they turned out great. I chilled the dough while making the filling and used a cookie scoop to form the balls. Thanks for sharing this recipe!
My 4 year old and I just finished baking a double batch of these. They are pretty darn good! I will definitely make these again, and will add a pinch of salt to the dough, as suggested by someone else. My son was VERY generous with the cinnamon (which he put in both the dough and the filling) and we did not add the other spices. We love cinnamon, so they are to our liking. Easy, fun for a 4 year old, and delicious. Thanks for posting!